For a shake-style vinyl exterior, compare panel profile, coverage, and the exact color before ordering. The Foundry 7-inch split shakes are best for a natural split-shake look, while its 10-inch staggered shakes offer a wider, varied profile. Polaris is a charcoal-gray option with cedar texture and a locking system. The CertainTeed listing names a straight-edge shingle style, but does not specify its color in the supplied details. Eagle 1 is black trim coil, not shake siding, and is included only as a coordinating finishing material.
| Product | Best suited for | Important detail |
|---|---|---|
| The Foundry 7-inch Split Shakes | Split-shake appearance | Single-course design |
| Polaris Homeside Select Double 7-inch | Charcoal-gray cedar texture | 50 square feet per box |
| The Foundry 10-inch Staggered Shakes | Wider staggered profile | Low thermal expansion |
| CertainTeed Cedar Impressions | Straight-edge shingle style | Confirm color and coverage |
| Eagle 1 Black Siding Coil | Black trim or flashing work | Not shake siding |
The Foundry 7-Inch Vinyl Split Shakes
Best for: Buyers who want a traditional split-shake profile and a more natural-looking installed surface. This listing is for one square, and the stated single-course design controls keyway width at the lap. Those details make it a relevant option for comparing a defined, consistent shake layout.
The listed design aims to create a natural installed look. However, the provided product details do not identify a color. If you need black siding, verify the available color and confirm that it is the intended shade before purchasing. Do not assume the pictured or listing variant is black.
Polaris Homeside Select Double 7-Inch Shake
Best for: Buyers open to charcoal gray who want a cedar-textured double 7-inch profile. The listing describes texture modeled from dozens of real cedar shakes, random seams, and a Tru-Lock locking system. It is a low-maintenance vinyl option according to the product details.
Each box is listed as covering 50 square feet and containing 10 pieces; the listing also gives 480 linear feet per box and a 37-pound box weight. Check the seller’s current packaging and coverage information when calculating quantities. The stated color is charcoal gray, so choose another listing if true black is required.
The Foundry 10-Inch Vinyl Staggered Shakes
Best for: Buyers comparing a wider staggered-shake appearance with a single-course design. The product is listed as one square and includes keyway-width control at the lap. Its stated low thermal expansion may also be relevant when comparing the product’s material behavior with other siding options.
The supplied details do not specify a color, so this is not a confirmed black option. Verify the selected color and the meaning of “one square” for the listing before planning coverage. Choose this profile if staggered shakes suit the exterior design better than the Foundry split-shake alternative.
CertainTeed Cedar Impressions Shingle Siding
Best for: Buyers considering a straight-edge shingle profile rather than a staggered shake. The listing identifies a double 7-inch Cedar Impressions style and a half-square package. This provides a useful comparison for shoppers deciding between a more uniform shingle appearance and irregular-looking shake profiles.
The supplied product information does not include detailed performance features or a confirmed color. Check the listing for the exact color, package coverage, and product specifications before ordering. Avoid treating the product name or image as confirmation that it is black.
Eagle 1 Black Siding Coil
Best for: Buyers seeking black coil material for trim, fascia cover, or flashing work alongside a siding project. The listing specifies a 4-inch-by-50-foot black aluminum/vinyl siding coil and says the roll includes matching stainless-steel trim nails.
This is an accessory material, not a shake-siding panel, so it cannot substitute for the main exterior cladding. Confirm the material and intended application for your project before purchasing. It is included because its black color may be relevant to finishing details, not because it meets the shake-siding search directly.
Buying Guide: How To Choose Black Vinyl Shake Siding
Is the product actually black?
Check the exact color variant and listing details before ordering. Of these options, Polaris is specifically described as charcoal gray, and Eagle 1 is specifically described as black—but it is trim coil, not shake siding. The Foundry and CertainTeed details supplied here do not confirm a black color. Charcoal and black can look different, so do not treat them as interchangeable.
Which shake profile should you compare?
Choose the 7-inch Foundry split shakes for a split-shake style. Compare the 10-inch Foundry staggered shakes if a wider staggered profile better fits the design. Polaris offers a double 7-inch format with cedar-inspired texture and random seams. CertainTeed is described as a straight-edge shingle, making it a different visual direction.
How much siding should you order?
Measure the areas to be covered and account for openings and installation needs. Compare the stated package units carefully: Foundry listings say one square, Polaris lists 50 square feet per box, and CertainTeed is described as a half square. Confirm current coverage and package quantities with the seller before calculating an order.
What details matter beyond appearance?
Compare the stated construction features, such as Polaris’s Tru-Lock system and Foundry’s single-course design. These descriptions are not a substitute for installation instructions. Confirm that the selected siding and accessory materials suit your project, and follow the manufacturer’s specifications.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which listed product is confirmed as black shake siding?
None of the supplied shake-siding details confirms a black color. The Eagle 1 coil is black, but it is an accessory, not shake siding.
Is charcoal gray the same as black siding?
No. Polaris is listed as charcoal gray. Verify color samples or the exact listing variant if the project requires black.
What is the difference between split and staggered shakes?
The Foundry products are identified as split shakes and staggered shakes, respectively. Compare their profiles and listing images to choose the appearance that fits the exterior.
Can siding coil replace vinyl shake panels?
No. The Eagle 1 listing describes coil material for trim, fascia cover, or flashing. It is not a shake-siding panel.
How can I confirm the right quantity?
Measure the cladding area, then verify the current package coverage and units for the exact product and color variant before ordering.